Cinema’s greatest scene: ‘Casablanca’ and ‘La Marseillaise’

Casablanca is widely remembered as one of the greatest films of all time, coming in at #2 on the AFI’s top 100 list and similarly regarded by many other critics. You can quibble with its exact rank, but it’s at least undeniable how iconic Casablanca remains. Even now, more than 70 years after its 1942 release, few movies have ever produced as many enduring quotes.

But when I think of the film, the first thing that comes to my mind isn’t “Here’s looking at you, kid,” or “We’ll always have Paris,” or the song “As Time Goes By,” or any of the other often best-remembered parts. For me, it’s always “La Marseillaise” — the dueling anthems between French refugees and their German occupants singing “Die Wacht am Rhein.” I’ve never found a movie scene yet that can match it. So now, at a time when people are once again turning to “La Marseillaise” for comfort in the face of adversity, I wanted to revisit what makes this scene so powerful.

The scene marks a major turning point in the film. Directly preceding this scene, the bar owner Rick (Humphrey Bogart) refuses to give or sell letters of transit to the war hero/revolutionary Victor Laszlo (Paul Heinreid). The letters of transit are the only hope of freedom for Victor, and his only chance at returning to his efforts at insurgency against the Nazis; Rick knows this, but is still too hurt and bitter that his lost love Ilsa (Ingrid Bergman) has chosen Victor over him. Rick’s refusal is essentially a Nazi victory, despite his careful attempts at framing his (in)actions as simple neutrality. The Germans, led by Major Strausser (Conrad Veidt), have established a de facto control over Casablanca, acting through the openly self-interested French Captain Louis Renault (Claude Rains).

After “La Marseillaise,” everything changes. The uneasy stalemate between Victor Laszlo and Major Strausser can no longer continue in the face of such open defiance of German power. Strausser orders Renault to find a pretense to shut down Rick’s — leading to arguably the film’s best exchange of dialogue. Strausser uses Ilsa to increase the pressure on Victor. Everything kicks into gear, as now Rick, Ilsa, Victor, and Louis are all forced into unpleasant decisions that will push the film toward its climax.

And it all begins with the anthems. As Rick and Victor are ending their disagreement, they hear the German soldiers in the bar below, joyfully and triumphantly singing “Die Wacht am Rhein.” The rest of the bar is made up largely of refugees from the German war machine, so the anthem feels almost like taunting, a callous display of German power over people seeking to escape their conquering. Even the ever-compliant Louis looks on at the singing with an expression that could be construed as disapproval, before glancing toward Rick to see what he’ll do. (Rick is a constant source of curiosity for Louis throughout the film.) This expression is the first and barest foreshadowing we receive of Louis’s eventual turn.

Louis_look

Victor spends only seconds taking in the scene in front of him before marching straight down to the bar’s band. As he passes, we see Ilsa watch him go by with a look of only partially contained dread. She knows this man and exactly what he’s about to do.

Ilsa_dread

Victor reaches the band and immediately demands that they play “La Marseillaise,” the French national anthem. Here we see, for the first and perhaps only time, what has made Victor such an important figure. There’s such a fierceness to him, an intensity that comes bursting out as he repeats his demand — “Play it” — less than second after first making it.

Victor_play_it

The band leader looks first to Rick for approval; the film had already established previously the absolute loyalty that Rick receives from his employees, in a scene where the bartender cuts off a patron on Rick’s orders despite protests for one more drink. Nothing that follows can happen without Rick’s assent. Bogart’s nod is such a small gesture, but carries such enormous weight. This is the first moment of Rick choosing a side, of joining in resistance in some small way.

Rick_nod

The band launches into “La Marseillaise” with Victor leading the singing, and within two seconds, the entire bar (except the Germans) has stood and joined him. Everyone was ready and waiting for this to happen, even if they didn’t know it: the kindling was already there, and Victor was the spark to light it. Major Strausser makes one attempt to rouse his soldiers into louder voices, but it’s no use. The Germans are but one small enclave, finding themselves within a community that’s filled with less traditional power but greater numbers and far superior zeal. Within moments, “La Marseillaise” has drowned out “Die Wacht am Rhein.”

Strausser is forced to give up and sit down in anger. That moment is also an example of one of the fascinating things about this scene, and why I’ve rewatched it by itself so many times. While the main focus in on just a small handful of characters, there are numerous people around the edges of shots whose actions and expressions add greatly to the emotions being played out. Take, for instance, the German officer to Strausser’s right (screen left), and the frustration and disgust on his face as he finally gives up the song.

Germans_lose

Now, only “La Marseillaise” is playing, as the voices rise to a swell. And we come to the heart of the entire scene: Yvonne. The story of Yvonne (Madeleine Lebeau) in Casablanca is perhaps the greatest example of economy in storytelling that I’ve seen. She appears in only three scenes in the entire film, with this one the last of them. Her total screen time combined is probably no more than a minute. And yet, in those brief stretches, we see an entire character arc play out; and what’s more, an arc that acts as a microcosm of the entire film.

We first see Yvonne early in the film, as she’s upset and confronting Rick because he’s rebuffed her after the two of them apparently shared a one-night stand. She tries to get drunker, but Rick takes that away from her too and has her sent home. The next time she appears, she’s at the bar and romantically entwined with a German soldier. A Frenchman takes exception to that pairing and starts a fight; Yvonne sides with the German. These two scenes, as brief as they are, tell us so much about her. She’s a broken woman, desperately seeking a man, possibly for love but more likely for a sense of protection and comfort in dangerous times. This desperation leads her all the way to the point of willingly collaborating and romantically pairing with a German.

But then, there’s “La Marseillaise.” A sudden and fervent outburst of patriotism that spreads like wildfire through the bar, overwhelming the Germans and awakening a passion in its singers. As the song begins to near its climax, we get a close-up of Yvonne, singing along with a very different kind of passion. We see tears streaking down her face and a pained expression as she sings. In just these few seconds, you can see a mountain of development and emotion. The same woman who was willing to compromise everything for her own security is realizing how far that compromise has made her fall; is realizing that she may never see the homeland she loves again; is realizing that she’d rather die a true Frenchwoman than live a traitor. It’s the same type of journey we see Rick travel more slowly throughout the movie, and shows perhaps the film’s most important motif: the choice between personal desire or safety and the greater good. How many people must have faced similar choices in the war — to collaborate or die? Yvonne isn’t just herself in this scene; she’s representing scores of people as she faces hard truths and makes her emotional break.

Yvonne_cries

We then move to Ilsa, and without a word, she conveys everything we need to know about her relationship with Victor. The movie wouldn’t be nearly as enduring without Bergman’s flawless portrayal of Ilsa. It’s easy to imagine a version of the film with Ilsa coming across as just a reductive caricature; her role in the plot revolves mostly around her being torn between two men whom she both loves. But Bergman imbues her with such subtle strength that Ilsa always feels like she has agency. Even when she tells Rick near the end that he must make the choices for both of them, it feels like a lie; she believes Rick will choose to keep her and him together, so telling him to make the choice is itself the choice.

But while Casablanca gives us flashbacks to Ilsa and Rick’s time together in Paris, the development of Ilsa and Victor is mostly expository. This scene is perhaps the best representation of how they fit together. Victor charged past Ilsa without a word, and we already saw the dread in her face as she knew what he was about to do. Now we get the first shot of her reaction to “La Marseillaise” after it’s begun. You can see it on her face and in the deep breaths she takes: she knows. She knows what this means for Victor, for his cause, for her, for their relationship. His open defiance in the face of the German soldiers will end all good hope they had of ever leaving Casablanca alive and together. You can see her heart breaking as she recognizes their predicament before anyone else in the room has even considered it.

Ilsa_sad

But then the camera cuts back to Victor, still singing triumphantly. There is such bravado in Henreid’s performance here; it’s the one scene where you can really see Victor as a revolutionary leader, capable of inspiring people into acts of defiance in the face of tyranny. When the camera reaches Ilsa again, her expression has softened, melted even, into one of love. A bittersweet love, perhaps, but an evident one. She knows that this reckless disregard for his own life is that same thing that once landed Victor in a concentration camp and threatens him again now in Casablanca, but that zeal must be the same reason she fell for him in the first place. Again, the economy of storytelling here is remarkable. Within a handful of seconds, an entire wordless story has been told: Ilsa’s sad resignation to their changing circumstances, Victor’s passionate defiance, and Ilsa’s acceptance of her husband, loving him for the fact that his greatest flaws are also his greatest virtues.

Victor_Ilsa_love

Ilsa’s acceptance is the final act needed for “La Marseillaise” to move on to reach its climax. Within less than just a couple of minutes, we have had the German aggression, Victor’s rebellion against it, Rick taking his first stand, the overwhelming passion of the French crowd, the redemption of Yvonne painting a story representative of the whole film, and Ilsa and Victor’s unconventional love in the face of adversity. All that remains is the final groundswell.

The power of this scene is helped, of course, by the indisputable fact that “La Marseillaise” is an incredible national anthem. While I’m by no means an expert, it’s the best one I’ve ever heard from any country, and its association in my mind with this scene is highly likely to always keep it there. But the scene is also helped by the people in it. The main actors are at their finest here, and I already mentioned how supporting actors gave great little tidbits in the German soldier part.

Yet perhaps the greatest thing in this scene is that most of the people in it weren’t actors at all; rather, director Michael Curtiz filled the scene with actual French refugees. Keep in mind, this movie came out in 1942 and was filmed at the height of World War II, at a time when Germany looked nearly unbeatable and Nazi occupation of France was indefinite. And here was a group of refugees from that occupation, given the chance to sing their anthem with defiant pride. For one brief moment, this wasn’t a movie. It was real life, and it was tragic, and it was brave. Reports have said that extras were crying on set during filming, and the passion is evident any time you look past the main actors to the background singers. Note, for instance, the furious arm pump by the man in the background behind the blonde woman at the left of the screen:

Passionate_singers

It’s also worth noting that the film is entirely in English; “La Marseillaise” is the only foreign language sequence I can recall, and it’s presented without subtitles. (You can find the English translation here; it’s very much a true battle song, in the goriest sense of the phrase.)  For some reason, that adds even more to its power for me. It’s unapologetically French, and derives much of its power from that. It was their anthem, at the time they needed it most. And for the film’s audience, most of whom were probably not speaking French, the intentional creation of a brief language barrier allows for a pure distillation of the passion of the singing; it’s not the words that matter, it’s what they represent to the people saying them. And what they represent is an ability to stand up in their darkest hour and show their oppressors that their pride will never be extinguished.

The song ends with one final shot of Yvonne, the final time we see her in the film. With wet cheeks, she yells “Vive la France!”

Finale

I truly believe this remains the greatest scene ever filmed. It’s filled with such raw power and emotion, showing a beacon of light in the midst of some of humanity’s darkest days. It tells so much of a story in such a brief moment, distilling numerous characters down to their cores and giving them developments and arcs through the merest of glances. It’s the turning point that pushes the plot and its characters to the point of no return, where a final and deadly confrontation will become necessary. All because of the power of a single song, and its ability to inspire, to create and destroy, to stoke passions and reconciliations and fears and loves. All because of “La Marseillaise.”

Vive la France, indeed.

Bookmark the permalink.

33 Comments

  1. Fantastic unpacking of a powderkeg

  2. Flavio Wolf de Aguiar

    Even the Germans were exiled, including Claude Veidt.

  3. Wow. Amazing. Thanks for that. The scene *always* brings tears to my eyes. Now I better understand why.

  4. One of the most moving scenes in all of cinema. I wonder if anyone knows, when the anthem begins, who the French lady is playing the guitar? She has a lovely voice and great spirit as she bursts into song. You see her again briefly as the anthem ends.

  5. Pingback: Why Editors? - Karin Cather Editorial Services LLC

  6. I agree. This is the single finest scene in any movie, anywhere, anytime. In the age of Trump, it has gained a new relevance in my heart.

  7. Brilliant exposition. I’ll only note that “Wacht am Rhein” also had no subtitles. Check its meaning: it’s clearly defensive, calling for resistance to (French, Napoleonic) invasion. In this it shares a perspective with “La Marseillaise”. The latter’s imagery is gory indeed; yet the intent is clearly defensive. It is *our* furrows that will be watered with impure blood. So motivating (to both sides) is the urgency of defence; so easily (to all sides) can it turn to aggression. A fascinating counterpoint to have these two anthems in this one scene.

    Again, my admiration and thanks for your exposition.

  8. The actors played the movie with their eyes more than any movie. Watch Rick on the balcony with Victor behind him and Ilsa as Victor goes past her. Best movie of all time.

  9. My grandmother stood up in the theatre & sang along! My mother, then in her late teens was mortified!!!

  10. Terrific analysis of a work of art

  11. A beautiful piece about a wonderful movie moment. You might be interested in knowing that Jean Renoir (of “Rules of the Game” fame, and so much else) made an entire movie about the French national anthem, called, appropriately, “La Marseillaise.” It’s the true story of the song, and takes place in the very earliest days of the revolution, when a contingent from Marseilles marched up through the French countryside to Paris to help expel the Prussians and Austrians who had invaded France in the hopes of quashing this budding threat to their reactionary monarchies. They brought the song with them, singing it on the way, and by the time they reached Paris, it had been adopted as the anthem of the new republic. Many of the scenes in the movie are nearly as stirring as the scene from Casablanca. There is a special resonance to the movie because Renoir, a committed “Popular Front” anti-Fascist, made the film in the 1930s at the height of the ultimately unsuccessful effort to rally the French against the growing power of the Nazis. The movie is hard to find — check some of the online pirate sites — but a definite treasure.

  12. Also note the contrasting use of the German national anthem, transposed to a minor key, at 1:50 at the end of the video…

  13. Thank you for this thoughtful distillation of the critical scene… There’s so much to unpack in “Casablanca”, some of which was created apparently without the creators being consciously aware… As for the climax of Rick, I think it may have happened a little earlier when he agrees to help the young refugee couple…. But, again, many thanks!

  14. Certainly one of the cinematic triumphs of the 20th century.

  15. George London, later an acclaimed opera singer, is an extra in the film and his voice can be heard very clearly powering the sound at times in this scene.

  16. I loved the brake down of how important this movie is to history and movie making. Today’s generation has missed out on the value of this movie.

  17. Outstanding job of exposition on the best scene in cinema.

  18. It is a perfect scene. As you point out, it reinforces relationships and values so deftly, especially with Victor. His resolute march to the bandstand is so remarkably powerful. No hesitation, his actions shout: We will not be bullied by these thugs! Those few moments say everything about his character’s motives, beautifully. I tear up during this scene every time.

    Nice summation. Cheers.

  19. Fantastic analysis and a very enjoyable read. I have watched that scene many times and it still gives me goosebumps. There is, as you so expertly dissect, so much going on in that scene, there is literally not one second wasted or redundant. Wonderful!

  20. Brilliant essay. Thanks.

  21. Exactly what I’ve been telling my Film Studies students here at Tolland High School.
    Great film — and by all odds it shouldn’t have been.

  22. Much of the emotional impact of the film has been attributed to the large proportion of European exiles and refugees who were extras or played minor roles. A witness to the filming of the “duel of the anthems” sequence said he saw many of the actors crying and “realized that they were all real refugees”.[22] Harmetz argues that they “brought to a dozen small roles in Casablanca an understanding and a desperation that could never have come from Central Casting”.[23] They were frequently cast as Nazis in war films, even though many were Jewish.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casablanca_%28film%29

  23. In 1937, Jean Renoir’s “The Grand Illusion” featured a similar scene , set in a WW1 POW prison.
    In this film, the prisoners are doing a burlesque number in drag. When news arrives of a French victory via smuggled newspaper, the band stokes up “La Marseillaise”, the performers remove their wigs and the lead the chorus while still in drag.
    The transition is so quick and stark that no tears are necessary.

    Michael Curtis must have have had this scene in mind.

  24. thank you for your commentary. I love this movie. there is just something about this movie that moves me. I think you nailed it. thanks. I never truly appreciated the weight of this scene as i will from now on.

  25. It’s worth noting that the last line of the anthem, just before “Vive la France” and the cut to the seated Germans, translates roughly as “an impure blood [our enemies’] will flow in the furrows of our fields”.

  26. Really wonderful write-up. Thank you so much.

  27. I don’t see the point of the label “greatest scene ever”. The media and popular culture is too obsessed with “best”, “greatest”, “biggest”, “funniest”.

    It’s a lazy way of morphing what is clearly your favorite into a fact. Of course it’s not possible to measure the “greatest scene ever” as we do the fastest Olympic sprinter ever. Personal taste is not a scientific unit of measurement, regardless of the film-theory analysis applied.

    A different title and description that elevates the worth of the scene is needed. “Greatest” is irritating and reminds me of faith-based descriptions of one’s religious God. “The greatest, end of story”. No, it’s not the end of the story by a long shot.

  28. Just a reminder that art is not for cowards.

    And look at us now.

    I am too ashamed about present to worry about future.

  29. This was so well written. Just watched Casablanca for the very first time today, and this incredible scene hasn’t left my mind. Just thinking about it makes me well up with tears… Yvonne’s face is just, wow. Thank you.

  30. Mega Ditto’s! I am in total agreement and I have been thinking similarly for years. This was absolutely the best and most compelling movie scene ever made. Congrats!
    Cordially,
    John Fuller

  31. Lovely commentary on the greatest movie ever. Many thanks.
    Ole R. Holsti

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *